© Idea Sandbox, LLC

Return to the Blog Home

June 22, 2007

meaningful marketing

"Greatest Promotion" Wouldn't Scale

Washington DC-area California Tortilla restaurants offered a $1-off your purchase if you beat the cashier playing Rock, Paper, Scissors.

A really cool idea.

I just heard about this from John Moore (from Brand Autopsy), who saw it on the website of Seth Godin, who read about it on the Freakonomics blog, who spotted it on the DCist blog, a site about all things Washington DC... Whoosh!

I agree this is a buzz-worthy promotion. Just look at the path it took to get posted here!

At his site, Seth comments that this idea showcases the front line worker. Makes them "part of the deal." He adds how great it is to allow them judgment. Perhaps even build enthusiasm among employees who are typically gears in the business machine.

Seth then suggests... What if you could get a free biscotti if you told a great joke to your Starbucks barista? Or what if the customer service team could give a prize to the nicest person who calls in that day?

A neat idea... but not at all realistic for a large company.

The California Tortilla idea works because they don't have very many locations. Smaller businesses can get away with bigger ideas like this because there is less 'exposure' to risk. What California Tortilla hoped was that enough people will talk about it... and visit the stores... and the $1-off discount offer would be offset by increased traffic for the day.

I'm sure that California Tortilla is prepared to give EVERYONE walking through their door on that day a dollar off. So, for them... the extra 100 customers who visit each of their 10? locations? That's a discount budget of $1,000. Not too risky.

While I like Seth's sentiment... Could you imagine if Wal*Mart or Starbucks actually tried this same promotion? It wouldn't work.

  • They'd have to be prepared to give away hundreds of thousands of dollars
  • I'm certain that the "rock" of the Rock Paper Scissors, would be used as what it really is - a fist - and someone would get hurt.

So often, the marketing tactics of small, fast growing companies are admired... But doing it while small isn't the same as when you're big.

The hotshots we were watching a few years ago... Build-A-Bear Workshop, Krispy Kreme, and Whole Foods were the darlings other companies wanted to be like. We were scrambling... benchmarking and doing store tours of these guys... How can we be more like them?

I've always argued, it is easy to do "cool" things when they had 5, 10... even 50 locations... Wait until they have more locations. It isn't the same. It isn't easy. And now, each of these businesses has growing pains...

  • Krispy-Kreme has had financial problems.
  • Build-A-Bear has gone public and now watered down their concept by offering pre-made stuffed animals in the toy aisle of Target.
  • Whole Foods is in a whole lot of hubbub in trying to get bigger.

So, realistically... what ideas would work for the big guys? What could a 7-Eleven, Starbucks, or Subway sandwich shop do? Anyone?

Sandboxes

February 16, 2007

meaningful marketing

Making Meaning to Customers, Employees

It is important to be reach and connect with customers and employees in a way that is meaningful... In a way that matters to them... Idea Sandbox talks a lot about meaningful marketing, but what IS IT that people find meaningful?

In their book Making Meaning: How Successful Businesses Deliver Meaningful Customer Experiences authors Steve Diller, Nathan Shedroff, and Darrel Rhea - through research of people from around the world - have discovered the types of experiences people find valuable.

Below are the fifteen experiences that emerged most often in their research. Presented in alphabetical order, I re-work the original content.

This list may come in handy when you're developing new products, briefing creative materials, or in an examination of your brand. You should apply this both inside and outside your organization.

Which of these is your product, company or brand providing?

15 Meanings

1. Accomplishment

Achieving goals and making something of oneself; a sense of satisfaction that can result from productivity, focus, talent, or status.

Examples:

  • American Express has long benefited from transmitting a hint of this meaning to its card holders by establishing itself as a credit card intended for those who are successful, and
  • Nike relies on the essence of this meaning for many in its “Just Do It” campaign.

2. Beauty

The appreciation of qualities that give pleasure to the senses or spirit. Of course beauty is in the eye of the beholder and thus highly subjective, but our desire for it is ubiquitous. We aspire to beauty in all that surrounds us, from architecture and fine furnishing to clothing and cars. Enormous industries thrive on the promise of beauty stemming from shinier hair, whiter teeth, and clearer skin. Beauty can also be more than mere appearance. For some, it is a sense that something is created “correctly” or efficiently with an elegance of purpose and use. Some companies distinguish themselves through the beauty of their design, such as...

Examples:

  • Bang & Olufsen audio equipment, and
  • Jaguar automobiles.

3. Community

A sense of unity with others around us and a general connection with other human beings. Religious communities, unions, fraternities, clubs, and sewing circles are all expressions of a desire for belonging. The promise and delivery of community underlies the offerings of several successful organizations. These businesses attract and support user communities who embody specific values tied to their products and services

Examples:

  • NASCAR with its centralizing focus on car racing and leagues of loyal fans that follow the race circuit,
  • Harley-Davidson motorcycles and their Harley Owners Group (HOG), and
  • Jimmy Buffet with his dedicated Parrotheads.

4. Creation

The sense of having produced something new and original, and in so doing, to have made a lasting contribution. Besides driving our species to propagate, we enjoy this experience through our hobbies, the way we decorate our home, in telling our stories, and in anything else that reflects our personal choices. Creation is what makes "customizable" seem like a desirable attribute, rather than more work for the buyer, for example, making the salad bar a pleasure rather than a chore.

5. Duty

The willing application of oneself to a responsibility. The military in any country counts on the power of this meaning, as do most employers. Duty can also relate to responsibilities to oneself or family, such as reading the daily paper to stay abreast of the news. Commercially, anything regarded as "good for you" that relays some sense of duty and the satisfaction it brings. These include...

Examples:

  • Vitamins,
  • Medications,
  • Cross-Your-Heart bras, and
  • Cushioned insoles.

6. Enlightenment

Clear understanding through logic or inspiration. This experience is not limited to those who meditate and fast. It is a core expectation of offerings from...

Examples:

  • Fox News, which promises “fair and balanced” reporting,
  • The Wall Street Journal, which many consider the ultimate authority for business news, and
  • Sierra Club, which provides perspective on environmental threats and conservation.

7. Freedom

The sense of living without unwanted constraints. This experience often plays tug-of-war with the desire for security; more of one tends to decrease the other. Nevertheless, freedom is enticing, whether it’s freedom from dictators, or in the case of...

Example:

  • Google, the freedom to quickly search the Web learning and interacting with millions of people and resources.

8. Harmony

The balanced and pleasing relationship of parts to a whole, whether in nature, society, or an individual. When we seek a work/life balance, we are in pursuit of harmony. Much of the aesthetic appeal of design depends on our personal desire for the visual experience of harmony. Likewise, when we shop at...

Example:

  • Target for a toaster that matches our mixer, we are in pursuit of harmony.

9. Justice

The assurance of equitable and unbiased treatment. This is the sense of fairness and equality that underlies our concept of "everyman" or Average Joe. It helps explain the immense popularity of products with a simple, impartial appeal to a very broad audience.

Examples:

  • The Ford Taurus,
  • Toyota Camry,
  • The ranch style house,
  • Levi jeans, and
  • White cotton T-shirts.

10. Oneness

A sense of unity with everything around us. It is what some seek from the practice of spirituality and what others expect from a good tequila. Although we don’t normally think of them as a company, the Grateful Dead sustained its revenues for decades building an experience that connected with its fans’ desire for oneness. Similarly, organizations that connects their members into nature or a broader sense of the world and are capable of evoking a meaning of oneness.

Examples:

  • Monterey Bay Aquarium, and
  • The United Nations.

11. Redemption

Atonement or deliverance from past failure or decline. Though this might seem to stem from negative experiences, the impact of the redemptive experience is highly positive. Like community and enlightenment, redemption has a basis in religion. Any sensation that delivers us from a less desirable condition to a more pleasing another one can be redemptive.

Examples:

  • Weight Watchers
  • Bliss spas, and
  • Grocery store candy aisles.

12. Security

The freedom from worry about loss. This experience has been a cornerstone of civilization but in the U.S. in particular, acquired increased meaning and relevance after 9/11. On the commercial side, the desire for this experience created the insurance business, and it continues to sell a wide range of products. Including...

Examples:

  • Automatic rifles,
  • Depends undergarments, and
  • Credit cards that offer protection from identity theft.

13. Truth

A commitment to honesty and integrity. This experience plays an important role in most personal relationships, but it also is a key component of companies which portray themselves as simple, upright, and candid. Such as...

Examples:

  • Whole Foods,
  • Volkswagen, and
  • Newman’s Own.

14. Validation

The recognition of oneself as a valued individual worthy of respect. Every externally branded piece of clothing counts on the attraction of this meaningful experience whether it’s Ralph Lauren Polo or Old Navy, as does Mercedes Benz, the Four Seasons hotel chain, and any other brand with status identification as a core value.

15. Wonder

Awe in the presence of a creation beyond one’s understanding. While this might sound mystical and unattainable, consider the wonder that Las Vegas hotels create simply through plaster and lights.

Examples:

  • Disney has been a master of this experience for decades, and
  • Technology companies routinely evoke awe as they enable their users to do what seemed impossible the year before.

The original, unedited list may be found on the Making Meaning website.

Sandboxes

February 7, 2007

meaningful marketing

Dutch McLocalization

In the Netherlands, McDonalds makes their menu locally relevant by offering a traditional Dutch food item - the Kroket.

The Wrapper

Notice the bicyclists... this makes this especially local... We all ride bikes in Amsterdam (not tandem though... if you look closely you see that's a kid on the back of the bike).

The Poster

"Met puur rundvlees" translated from Dutch means... "With pure beef."



Sandboxes

December 12, 2006

REMARKABILITY

How to Be Different: Create "Wow!"



How do you break your company or product away from the pack of sameness?

Welcome to the first in a series of guides highlighting techniques marketing experts suggest to be different and build awareness... Here are some thoughts by Tom Peters...

Who:

Tom Peters

What:

"WOW!"

What is it?

Wow is "stepping out (individuals at all levels in a firm and independent contractors) and standing out (corporations and organizations) from the growing crowd of look-alikes. Being average has never had much appeal. Better to fail with flair in pursuit of something neat..."

How is is done?

Tom offers 210 stories - some short, some long - which are examples of people and companies doing WOW things... While Tom doesn't offer step-by-step instructions on creating a WOW idea, you will be inspired by his examples. Examples are arranged into these chapters:
  • Starters
  • Getting Things Done
  • Milk, Cookies and Managing People
  • Pens, Toilets, and Businesses That Do It Differently
  • Just Say No to Commodities (And Yes to Free Spirits)
  • Breaking the Mold
  • The Wacky World (or [mostly] what have you done about Asia today?)
  • Searching for the Diversity Advantage
  • Tomorrow's Strange Enterprises
  • Entrepreneurs' Dreams
  • Lists!
  • Attaining Perpetual Adolescence
  • Parting Shots

Check Out

Books Online Articles by Tom Peters in Fast Company Magazine
(Don't let the dates of 1999 dissuade you - this writing is just as relevant today as it was then)

Next post, Doug Hall and Dramatic Difference...

Sandboxes

December 11, 2006

REMARKABILITY

Create Awareness by Being Very Different

Different

Many of us are charged with the job of building awareness of our brand, company, product, and/or ourselves. The best minds in business agree, to get noticed you need to be different. Not just slightly, but very different...

Over the next several posts I'll share the strategies these marketing gurus offer on:

how to be different and

how to gain awareness.

I will qualify this with... I'll only be highlighting the kind of differentiation/awareness strategies that are: authentic, positive, ethical, appropriate for your brand, meaningful, and believable.

The discussion starts tomorrow with Tom Peters and Wow!...

Sandboxes

November 6, 2006

meaningful marketing

Blending Entertainment with Product Benefit

Blendtec is a company that manufacturer drink blenders. Big deal... there are a bunch of companies out there making blenders... (In fact, if you're like me you've owned several of them, and they've all been a piece of junk...)

But Blendtec has a story to tell about the quality of their products and they do it in an entertaining and educational way. The "Will It Blend?" portion of their website features video clips from the test lab where they blend everything from a bottle of beer (glass bottle, metal cap and all), a can of Coke (unopened soda with can), turn marbles into dust, and pulverize a rake handle (using the 'soup' blend speed).

Next time I need a blender, I'm going to think twice about buying one at a discount store.

Blendtec obviously has some of the most powerful blenders in the market - perhaps the world. They easily could have stopped at simply demonstrating the multiple speed settings and explain how to make a smoothie or make your own peanut butter from peanuts... (and they DO do that...) but they go further and demonstrate the power of their product by putting all sorts of 'non-blendable' and unthinkable items into their machines. They let the blender demonstrate its remarkability.

Check out the videos for yourself. You'll be amazed.

Could your products stand up to this type of abuse? Do your products have a similar story to tell that could be just as engaging? Go make a movie.

Sandboxes

October 31, 2006

meaningful marketing

Expats without Pumpkins

I'm an "expat." That's short for expatriate... someone who is living outside the country of their legal residence. I'm an American living in the Netherlands.

I am a guest in this country and firmly believe that you should embrace the celebrations and customs of your host country. (Just like I'd expect of expats in the United States).

With that said, there are a few American traditions I miss... One of them is pumpkin carving. Perhaps it's just that I haven't found a pumpkin source yet... (I need a Gouda & Gourds shop...)

For those who are pumpkin-less and want to carve, I found a virtual pumpkin carving site.

Sandbox-o-lantern
carved it myself

This Halloween site is part of a larger and interesting marketing site called Theo Worlds... Here's what they say about themselves...

We believe in the power of a message that is informative and fun at the same time. With all of the information that people are dealing with today, it is more important than ever to make your message stand out.

Our solutions are as serious as they are fun. That's why most of our online products are Flash based games - a perfect viral marketing tool.

Let us put our creativity, ideas and skills to work for you. Tell us about your business and your goals and we will work to create a unique and original solution for you.


Interesting how a pumpkin post turned into a creative marketing topic...

I know... it's barely a substitute as there are not seeds to toast, nor pumpkin guts to get all over your hand and arms... but still a bit of fun...

Happy Halloween!


lightbulb-o-lantern.jpg

Sandboxes

July 18, 2006

meaningful marketing

Locally Relevant Koffie

Be relevant to your customers is life/business rule #1.

This outdoor ad at a tram stop in Amsterdam caught my eye for two reasons... 1) It's for a new coffee product. 2) It's very locally relevant.

Very clever... It's a 'map' of an Amsterdam-like city. But it's also the shape of a woman drinking the new product.
[click on the below image for a larger view]

Cafe Fresco Ad Image

Below is a detail of a section around the ear/eyes... you can see street names, etc.

Cafe Fresco Detail

The text reads...
New
Cafe Fresco
The ice-cold coffee drink for when you're on the go!

This ready-to-drink cold coffee beverage is being produced by two large Dutch brands... Douwe Egberts coffee company (which is actually owned by Sara Lee... and may be better known in the US for their collaboration with Philips to create the Senseo coffee maker) and Campina a dairy company.

The Campina site states... "The nice coffee of Douwe Egberts and the ice-cold fresh milk of Campina form the perfect basis for this purely Dutch ice-cold coffee drink."

The website for Cafe Fresco features young, active good-looking Dutch people, doing active fun Dutch stuff... shopping, catching a train, and even a guy falling on his bike...

The product is being sold in grocery stores as well as gas stations.

This drink is a knock-off of very similar to Starbucks ready-to-drink fresh (i.e. short expiration date) called Discoveries, which is sold throughout Asia.

Starbucks Discoveries Product

Fun Facts:

  • Coffee to-go is a newer concept in the Netherlands.
  • Coffee is served everywhere in Amsterdam... Cafes, restaurants, and machines at work... you even get it free while doing business at the bank or while shopping in the grocery store.
  • It's polite to offer/have coffee ready when a service or repairperson does work at your home.
  • The Dutch were the first to grow coffee in Europe.

Sandboxes

June 12, 2006

meaningful marketing

Time. Talent. Treasure.

A friend who works at Seattle's Best Coffee often uses a filter called "Time, Talent, Treasure" to help her make important business decisions. She learned this from a co-worker years ago and passes it along... (Now I pass it to you).

Is it worth our Time, Talent, and Treasure? Below are suggested questions to ask about the project, plan, or idea...

Time

  • Is it worth the time investment?
  • Are there better/more effective things we could be doing with our time?
  • Does the effort provide a worthwhile return?
  • Is there a way to do this that will allow it to take less time... make it easier (but without compromising the integrity or watering down the idea?)
  • Is there a way to make the time work harder for you? (i.e. if you're already having a regional meeting pulling together your management team - is there something else you can do to all value to their time?)

Talent

  • Is this something I should be working on?
  • Should it be delegated?
  • Is it part of my role?
  • Is there someone else more skilled with a project like this?
  • Is it something our employees (talent) should be focused on?

Treasure

Treasure can be viewed from two perspectives... Money as treasure... Brand as treasure.

Money

  • Is it worth our financial investment?
  • Should we spend against this?
  • Is there a better use of our cash?

Brand

  • Is it worth our brand investment?
  • Should we lean our brand on this?
  • Does it strengthen our brand or does it stretch it?

Next time you are in a planning, strategic, or tactical meeting... try using this filter on some of the most important questions.

If it isn't worth your time, or talent, or treasure is there a way to modify it so it is? If you can't figure out a practical way - perhaps it's not worth doing.

Sandboxes

March 31, 2006

meaningful marketing

Word of IMouth Advertising

This must be family week at Idea Sandbox. Two posts about mom... here and here... and now one involving my brother, Jeff. I was instant messaging with Jeff... and was explaining to him to give the show "My Name is Earl" another chance... I thought the writing had improved and the characters have become more interesting since the first episodes. He was in the middle of having a bowl of cereal for dinner. (How Seinfeld of him). He sent me this message...

GrapeNutsChat.jpg

Do you think I'll try the new Grape Nuts with Raisins and Honey? (Actually called Grape Nuts Trail Mix Crunch). Yes.

Why? He's my brother and I trust him.

Do you think he'll try watching a few more episodes of "My Name Is Earl?" Yes.

Why? He trusts my judgement.

And so it goes. Perhaps neither of us will like the other's recommendation, but there will be one more household watching and one more box purchased.

I'll follow up with the results in a later post!

Sandboxes